Score: 7

"pretty good"

submission: DotA Leavers 3 (Nerdrage)

date: May 27, 2009

While I don't think it was that great of an actual animation, I really enjoyed the creativity and inside jokes in this. I'm pretty sure someone who doesn't play dota wouldn't have a clue what's going on, but as I do play dota, I loved all the comments and jokes, like the type of person who plays stealth assassin and the stealing of Aegis. My favorite part was the chariots of fire playing while SA ran towards spawn juxtaposed against the out-of-mana Zues. In every part you incorporated music really well, and it helped to make the video really enjoyable. Well done overall

Score: 10

"Thank you so much!"

submission: Brawl Funnies [Dick 1]

date: May 9, 2009

I cannot express how much I've despised the brawl taunt series, and its so DAMN REFRESHING to see people making fun of it instead of blindly praising it!! Nothing angered me more than the swarms of prepubescent idiots that flocked to taunts and built it up as some masterpiece instead of the shithole it is, so thanks for bringing people back to reality.

Animation was top notch in a lot of the skits, I especially liked Ukinojoe's, rtil's, and whoever made the "And a whole lot of egoraptor's ideas!" parts. Very well done, it made fun of it exactly how it should have, and I lol'ed thoroughly.

So again, thank you. I have needed this sort of mockery of the series for a long time, and I think if I hadn't seen this soon I would have combusted. You all are gods.

Score: 10

"awesome!"

submission: Pico 09

date: May 7, 2009

That was incredible!! So refreshing to see a satirical take on pico day, not just another fighting reference. All the characters, and the innocence and randomness of it was just fantastic, I loved every little detail. The gay jokes were awesome too, haha, im sure people didnt like 'em but it really made fun of pico day right where it counts.

Fantastic overall, I laughed/smiled throughout. Can't wait to see more

Score: 8

"Pretty badass"

submission: Necro Bitch

date: September 29, 2009

Cool stuff, this was a lot of fun to listen to. The intense bass on each quarter note really creates an intense drive that makes this such a pleasure to listen to, and I really enjoy the progression at the beginning. It starts in a way that sorta makes you say, "What the fuck is this?". But then as more is added, the rhythm becomes more and more hypnotic, and you get sucked into the beat with each component added. Like I said, a really enjoyable listen.

The main critique I have is a general lack of variety. I understand you're going for a hard DnB style song, but I don't think that really excuses the repetitiveness of the song as a whole. Obviously this is a matter of personal taste, but to me, I feel like the song would be greatly improved with a little more variation from the beat you having driving throughout. My favorite section comes at 2:36, I love that breakdown. More parts like from 2:36 on, where things are dropping out and changing, would greatly improve the song in my opinion.

Overall, great job. 5/5 and 8/10

Score: 10

"Nice!"

submission: Game 3 Attempt #1

date: September 21, 2009

Damn, I really like this! I agree with you, this envisions quite perfectly what I hear when I see game 3 in its current state. The bounciness and energy of the whole piece is great, and its got some good ups and downs, and I feel this would be great as background music. I always enjoy hearing your stuff, keep up the great work! And please PM anytime you release a new song, I'd always be happy to offer up my opinions :D

Score: 9

"Pretty cool"

submission: [haxxy] This Afternoon (DEMO)

date: September 10, 2009

Overall, I really enjoyed this. This sounds and melodies all intertwine very well, and it's got a very cool feel overall. In terms of the song itself, its professional quality, very well made. The main qualm I have with the song however, is the vocals. The quality of singing just isn't there for me; it sounds like someone who really doesn't know how to sing, trying to sing, and it makes it hard for me to appreciate the high quality of everything else. This song would be fantastic if the vocals sounded better, and while I realize you're going for a stylized sort of singing, it just doesn't work for me. Like I said though, I think the rest of the song is top notch, just as long as the vocals sound amateur-ish, it brings the rest of the song down.